Thursday 2 June 2011

Macbook Pro - i7, apple


Let's assume you're confused between buying the "standard" $1199 Macbook Pro 13 and this "high end" $1499 Macbook Pro 13.



I'll just say it straight up.



This "High end" model is still not a smart buy when compared to the "standard" Apple MacBook Pro MC700LL/A 13.3-Inch Laptop



The ONLY differences between the two 2011 MBP 13's are minor and consist of a super small processor speed difference and hard drive space.



The standard MBP 13 has a 2.3GHz dual-core Intel Core i5 processor + a 320 gb 5400 rpm hard drive while the high end MBP 13 has a 2.7GHz dual-core Intel Core i7 processor + a 500 gb hard drive.



For value conscious consumers, I've pasted Speedmark 6.5 and Geekbench results below. Speedmark is Macworld Lab's standard test tool for benchmarking Macs. It's used to test overall speed and efficiency of macs. Geekbench is the most recognized benchmarking software for Mac.



Speedmark 6.5 results:

2011 Macbook Pro 13



13" MacBook Pro 2.3GHz Core i5 dual-core - Score = 140

13" MacBook Pro 2.7GHz Core i7 dual-core - Score = 155



Only 15 points more. Not even a 15% difference.



Geekbench Benchmark results

13" MBP 2.3 GHz dual i5 2011: 5948

13" MBP 2.7 GHz dual i7 2011, 6796



A difference of 848 points - which equals up to a 12% difference.



So you're paying $300 more (20% of the cost of the $1499 MBP 13 or 25% of the cost of the standard $1199 MBP 13) for a 12% difference, a 400 mhz processor speed difference (not at all major in any way as seen in the benchmarks) and a 180 gb hard drive space increase.



EVERYTHING else is is the same in both models, from the 1280 x 800 resolution 13 inch LED screen to the Intel HD 3000 integrated graphics to the Superdrive DVD burner to the Thunderbolt Port,FaceTime HD Camera, backlit keyboard, 4gb ram, two USB 2.0 ports, Wi-fi B/G/N, bluetooth 2.1 and Gigabit ethernet



The software included in both models is the same too, Mac OS X Leopard 10.6 and the iLife suite of content creation tools. A 1 year warranty on parts and 90 day telephone technical support is also standard on both models



What if you chose to buy the standard MBP 13?



If you did that, you could then buy a 500 gb hard drive yourself Western Digital Scorpio Blue 500 GB Bulk/OEM Hard Drive 2.5 Inch, 8 MB Cache, 5400 RPM SATA II WD5000BEVT for $ 55 and install it yourself in your standard MBP 13 which would then have a hard drive just as large as the higher end MBP 13.The installation instructions are included in the MBP 13 manual and it doesn't void the warranty. Installation videos are also available online.



And you'd still have $245 left to buy an AppleCare Protection Plan for Mac Laptops 13 Inches and Below (NEWEST VERSION) or a SquareTrade 3-Year Laptop/Tablet Warranty Plus Accident Protection (Laptop/Tablet $1000-1250) to protect your shiny new MBP 13 for 2 more years after the standard one year warranty is up.



Until Apple actually puts in a major differentiation feature or upgrade in the higher end MBP 13, I'd recommend you shop smart, save your money and opt for the standard Apple MacBook Pro MC700LL/A 13.3-Inch Laptop. It's 99% identical to the more expensive MBP 13 and a much stronger product when it comes to the value for money factor. And use the rest of the money to buy a warranty and a hard drive upgrade if you feel like.



Hope this helps!



NOTE - A fellow Amazon customer Diane A (Her comment can be seen in the comments section of this review) has spoken to an Apple rep and she had this to say "Even the Apple Rep that I spoke with at the Apple store recommended the MBP 13 as is and said the differences were not worth the extra money. Said the average user would not notice any differences in the 2 units - just cost."



Something to think about. Thank you.





UPDATE - Professional review site Notebookcheck.net did a review of both Machines. I've posted the links to the full reviews below as well as summary quotes.



Quote # 1 - referring to the performance difference between the standard and high end MBP 13 - ( link - [...]



"It's also interesting to take a look at how the model at hand measures up to the weaker MacBook Pro 13 version with a Core i5 processor. The less powerful model performs 91% as quickly as the Core i7 model, that is, only slightly slower."



Quote # 2 - Referring to the battery life of the standard MBP 13 ( link - [...]



"The model we're reviewing here trumps the more powerful version of the MBP13 with an 11-16% longer battery life in all test scenarios (note: wifi test results not comparable)"



So the standard MBP 13 has better battery life by 11 to 16%, has 91% of the "higher end" MBP 13's performance ability AND costs 25% less. Apple MacBook Pro MC724LL/A 13.3-Inch Laptop - Notebook - Macbook Pro - Apple - I7'


Detail Products
Detail Reviews
Click here for more information